Navigating School Choice in Alabama: The Alabama Accountability Act Explained

Navigating School Choice in Alabama: The Alabama Accountability Act Explained

As a Black parent in Alabama, you may have heard talk about “school choice” — but the term can be confusing, politically charged, and difficult to translate into practical decisions for your family. What does school choice actually look like in Alabama? What rights do you have if your child is attending a struggling school? And what are the real trade-offs involved in exercising those rights?

This post breaks down Alabama’s primary school choice legislation — the Alabama Accountability Act — in plain language, so you can make fully informed decisions about your child’s education.

What Is the Alabama Accountability Act?

The Alabama Accountability Act (AAA), passed in 2013, created a framework for school choice in Alabama by establishing two primary mechanisms: the right to transfer students from failing public schools, and a Scholarship Granting Organization (SGO) tax credit scholarship program.

The law defines a “failing school” based on academic performance data from the ALSDE. Specifically, schools that have been identified as failing under the state’s accountability system for multiple consecutive years are placed on the failing school list. This list is updated periodically by the ALSDE and is publicly available.

The Transfer Option for Failing Schools

If your child attends a school that has been identified as failing under the Alabama Accountability Act, you have the right to request a transfer to a non-failing public school within the same school district, or to a public school in a neighboring district if that district agrees to accept transfer students.

The process involves:

  1. Confirming that your child’s school is on the ALSDE’s failing schools list (available at alsde.edu).
  2. Submitting a transfer request to your local school district’s central office — typically at the beginning of the school year.
  3. Understanding that transfer availability depends on space in receiving schools.

While this option sounds straightforward, it comes with practical challenges — especially for Black families in rural areas or under-resourced urban neighborhoods. Transportation is not always provided, which creates a barrier for families without reliable access to a vehicle. And in districts where most schools are struggling, the pool of non-failing transfer destinations may be limited.

The Tax Credit Scholarship Program

The second component of the Alabama Accountability Act is a scholarship program funded through private donations that receive a dollar-for-dollar state income tax credit. Here’s how it works:

  • Individuals and businesses donate to approved Scholarship Granting Organizations (SGOs).
  • Those donors receive a credit against their Alabama state income taxes equal to the amount donated.
  • SGOs use those funds to award scholarships to eligible students — primarily students who attend failing public schools or who come from households at or below a certain income threshold.
  • Scholarship recipients can use the funds to attend participating private schools.

For Black families, this program represents a genuine option — but it requires navigating an application process, understanding which private schools participate and whether they are a good fit for your child, and making a real assessment of what you gain and what you leave behind.

What to Consider Before Choosing

Choosing to leave a public school — even a struggling one — is never a simple decision. Public schools are required by law to serve every student, including students with disabilities, English learners, and those experiencing homelessness. Private schools, including those accepting scholarship students under the AAA, are not subject to all of the same legal requirements. Before applying for a scholarship, ask the private school:

  • Do they have services for students with IEPs or 504 plans?
  • What is their discipline policy, and what are their suspension/expulsion rates for Black students?
  • Do they employ Black teachers or administrators?
  • What does their curriculum look like in terms of cultural representation and Black history?
  • What are their academic outcomes for students who transfer in from public schools?

The Bigger Picture — Systemic Advocacy Alongside Individual Choice

It is important that individual school choice decisions not distract from the systemic advocacy needed to improve all Alabama public schools. When Black families leave failing schools without demanding that those schools be fixed, the schools often continue to decline — leaving behind the most vulnerable students who cannot exercise choice. The ideal approach combines informed individual decision-making with organized community pressure to improve every school in the district.

BA4E supports informed choice while also advocating for the systemic investments that make choice less necessary — fully funded schools, qualified teachers, and equitable resources for all Alabama students.


Actionable Steps for Parents

  • Check the ALSDE failing schools list at alsde.edu to see if your child’s school is currently designated as failing.
  • Contact your district’s central office to ask about the transfer application process and deadlines if you are eligible.
  • Research SGOs operating in Alabama to find scholarship opportunities; eligibility and availability vary by organization.
  • Visit and ask questions of any private school before accepting a scholarship — interview them as thoroughly as they would interview you.
  • Connect with BA4E for support in understanding your rights under the Alabama Accountability Act and navigating the application process.
  • Advocate simultaneously — whether you choose to transfer or stay, add your voice to the demand that failing schools receive the resources and leadership changes they need.
  • Understand transportation logistics before committing to a transfer school; ask the district if transportation assistance is available.
Scroll to Top